California
New Construction Buyer Guide
California maintains one of the most comprehensive statutory frameworks for new construction homebuyer protection in the United States. The state limits liquidated damages for owner-occupied residential purchases to three percent of the purchase price, a cap that prevents builders from imposing disproportionate financial penalties for buyer default. California's broader consumer protection statutes, including the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act and the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, provide additional avenues for homebuyers to pursue claims against builders.
California's Right to Repair Act (Civil Code Sections 895-945.5), commonly referred to as SB 800, establishes a detailed pre-litigation process for construction defect claims in residential properties. The statute defines specific building standards, sets forth a notice-and-cure process, and provides builders with the opportunity to inspect and repair defects before the homeowner can file suit. SB 800 applies to homes sold on or after January 1, 2003, and it provides a comprehensive framework that governs the majority of new construction defect disputes in the state.
California also provides longer statutes of limitations for construction defect claims compared to many other states. Latent defect claims carry a ten-year statute of repose, and patent defects are subject to a four-year limitations period. The California Public Contract Code addresses material substitution practices, including provisions governing "or equal" substitution clauses in construction contracts. These extended timelines and substitution protections give California homebuyers a broader window and more defined standards for pursuing claims.
Key Protections
California Civil Code Section 1675 limits liquidated damages for buyer default in owner-occupied residential purchases to three percent of the purchase price. This cap prevents builders from imposing disproportionate forfeitures in the event the buyer is unable to close.
California's Right to Repair Act (Civil Code Sections 895-945.5) establishes detailed building standards and a pre-litigation process for construction defect claims. The statute defines specific standards for each component of the home and provides a structured path for resolution before litigation.
California provides a ten-year statute of repose for latent construction defects and a four-year limitations period for patent defects. These extended timelines give homebuyers a longer window to discover and pursue claims compared to most other states.
The California Consumer Legal Remedies Act prohibits unfair and deceptive business practices in consumer transactions, including residential real estate purchases. The CLRA provides for actual damages, injunctive relief, and in certain cases, attorneys' fees.
The California Public Contract Code includes provisions addressing "or equal" substitution clauses in construction. These provisions establish standards for when and how a builder may substitute materials, providing buyers with a framework for evaluating whether substitutions meet contractual specifications.
Key Risks
The Right to Repair Act's pre-litigation process, while providing structure, can delay a homeowner's ability to file suit. The notice-and-cure timeline gives the builder control over the initial repair process, and homeowners must navigate procedural requirements to preserve their claims.
Despite California's strong consumer protection framework, arbitration clauses in builder contracts are generally enforceable under federal preemption principles. The Federal Arbitration Act limits California's ability to categorically invalidate arbitration provisions.
Builder contracts in California may include express warranties that are narrower than the protections available under SB 800 or common law. Buyers should compare the contractual warranty terms against the statutory standards to understand the full scope of their coverage.
California's construction defect framework is among the most complex in the nation. The interplay between SB 800, common law warranties, the CLRA, and local building codes can create procedural challenges for homeowners who are not represented by experienced counsel.
Notable Cases
The court addressed the scope of SB 800's pre-litigation procedures and their relationship to common law causes of action, clarifying when homeowners may pursue claims outside the statutory framework.
The court examined the enforceability of arbitration provisions in builder contracts in the context of SB 800 claims, addressing the tension between the statutory framework and contractual dispute resolution mechanisms.
Advice for California Buyers
- 1Understand the three percent liquidated damages cap. Under California law, the builder cannot impose a forfeiture greater than three percent of the purchase price for an owner-occupied residential purchase. If your contract specifies a higher amount, it may be unenforceable.
- 2Familiarize yourself with the SB 800 Right to Repair Act process. This statute governs most construction defect claims for homes sold after January 1, 2003, and requires a specific notice-and-cure procedure before litigation can commence.
- 3Take advantage of California's longer statutes of limitations. Latent defects carry a ten-year statute of repose, giving you a wider window to discover and pursue claims than most other states provide.
- 4Review material substitution clauses in your contract. California law addresses "or equal" substitution standards, and you should understand what the builder is permitted to substitute and under what conditions.
- 5Consider retaining a California construction defect attorney before signing the purchase agreement. The complexity of California's statutory framework, including the interplay between SB 800, the CLRA, and common law, makes professional guidance particularly valuable.
- 6Hire an independent home inspector before closing. While California's building code standards are stringent, an independent inspection provides verification that the home meets those standards at the time of delivery.
Have a new construction contract? Scan it for $49 at fineprint.homes
Scan Your Contract